So me, being me, clicked on it and read through the journal entry and some things stood out at me.
I think it was the way it started with "Ever Evolving", when you think about how many differennt adaptions of Sherlock Holmes' adventures there are, it's incredible. Sherlock Holmes holds the record for being the 'most portrayed movie character', and according to the World Records site, he's been portrayed in over 238 films, played by over 30 actors right back since 1900, and even now more adaptions are being made. And that's not including people on stage and the parodies of people on YouTube.
That's over 100 years of Sherlock Holmes, in movies alone. TV series, radio series, comics books, video games.
Now I guess, with all of those adaptions, we do have favourites somewhere in it all. I mean, over 30 actors and we're meant to love them all equally? I've not seen a majority of them. I've seen the BBC's Benedict Cumberbatch, Granada's Jeremy Brett, and Guy Ritchie's Robert Downey Jr. They all bring something different to the table but each play the brilliant detective, I can't choose.
I think it's because they all play Sherlock Holmes and I love Sherlock Holmes in general.
Now back to this Journal entry I found, Techgnotic adds some questions for the reader. Which I loved and enjoyed answering.
Does it bother you when the depiction of a favorite fictional literary character is radically altered in film or on TV over and over again? Or does it all depend on the quality of the depiction and the story?
I think in some way it bothers me that people will get bored of the idea of Sherlock Holmes, and I pray to god that they don't because the stories are amazing and I think they should be shared in any way possible.
But for whether I like a portrayal, depends how well they do it and whether I find the whole adaption enjoyable.
2 Most of the muscle-bound comics superheroes beginning in the 1930s-40s also seemed to possess great intellects along with their dominating physiques. Do you think this was because of being influenced by the Holmes character of 30 years before? Or just a coincidence – since if as character has a super-strength body, why not a matching super-strength brain?
This is a good question, I had to think for a while but then I thought, what's the point of brawn if you don't have the brains to use them? Hence the 'super strength brain' bit, but whereas I believe Sherlock Holmes is more about puzzles with action and lot of superheroes seem to be about the fighting action with little puzzles.
3 Which Sherlock Holmes novels or short stories have you read?
I have this huge book of the Complete Stories but I've only read few a few of them, A Study in Scarlet, Sign of the Four, Scandal in Bohemia and a few others, but I'm slowly making my way through them in my spare time :D
This is a good question, I had to think for a while but then I thought, what's the point of brawn if you don't have the brains to use them? Hence the 'super strength brain' bit, but whereas I believe Sherlock Holmes is more about puzzles with action and lot of superheroes seem to be about the fighting action with little puzzles.
3 Which Sherlock Holmes novels or short stories have you read?
I have this huge book of the Complete Stories but I've only read few a few of them, A Study in Scarlet, Sign of the Four, Scandal in Bohemia and a few others, but I'm slowly making my way through them in my spare time :D
4 In which way do you prefer your adventure story hero to achieve his/her final victory:
- His/her superior intellect; puzzle-solving skills.
- Physical strength and fighting skills, and a little good luck.
- A mix of both brains and brawn.
- Through lone wolf personal action; breaking of rules & protocol.
- Through leadership of a team of relative equals.
- Other - Please Elaborate. I would love to know which story ending achievement tropes I might have left off of this list
5 Who was/is your favorite Sherlock Holmes -- and why?
- Basil Rathbone
- Jeremy Brett
- Peter Cushing
- Christopher Lee
- Robert Downey, Jr.
- Benedict Cumberbatch
- Other
Probably Jeremy Brett, I find him hilarious, in one of his first episodes he's like "And why is Sherlock Holmes cheerful?"
And Watson, David Burke, replies "Sherlock Holmes is cheerful, so Sherlock Holmes must have a case." And Jeremy Brett is all "HA! I have a case!" It was brilliant.
6 If Sherlock Holmes and Liara T'Soni are the District 3 Tributes in the 74th Annual Hunger Games. Who survives and why?I'm just sat here thinking "Well...neither, Katniss and Peeta does." But if I had to choose. Sherlock, cause I don't know who Liara T'Soni is....Mass Effect, I think? But then, in the 74th, they both could win considering the changed rule and I'm sure they'd figure out how to both survive between them.
And Speaking of Sherlock Holmes, I leave you with this parody video my friend sent me after she saw me with my deerstalker.
So that's me done for another blog-day.
Happy reading and I'll see you next time.